When parents separate, most child maintenance is handled routinely through the Child Maintenance Service (CMS). Some parents go to considerable lengths to avoid paying child maintenance by minimising their apparent income, moving abroad, or putting property under someone else's name to avoid enforcement. However, a recent family court decision shows that, while the courts have the tools and perspicacity to see through such manoeuvres, they have little patience for them.
How are children provided for financially?
Beyond the standard maintenance calculation, a parent can ask the court to make financial provision for a child under Schedule 1 to the Children Act 1989. This is especially pertinent for unmarried parents who have no access to the financial-remedy process of a formal divorce. Schedule 1 allows the court to order lump sums, transfer or settle property, or command financial orders for payments towards a child's needs.
Crucially, where there is a real risk that ongoing payments will not be made, the court can order a one-off "capitalised" lump sum instead – a single figure representing future maintenance – so that the child's support does not depend on the continued cooperation of the parent.
In the case in question, a divorced father had previously been ordered to pay a capitalised lump sum of almost £150,000, plus costs, to make financial provision for his three children, which was adjusted to a lump sum payment of £135,000. In the interim, he had moved overseas and had paid nothing in respect of child maintenance for some time. While awaiting the Court's decision, he put his two English properties on the market and signed a declaration of trust purporting to give the entire ownership of one property to his sister. Correspondence with his own lawyers revealed that his specific aim was to ensure that he had no remaining UK assets to satisfy his children's rightful claim.
The Court set that transfer aside and invoked Section 423 of the Insolvency Act 1986, which allows a court to unwind a transaction made at an undervalue, such as a gift, where the purpose was to put assets beyond the reach of a claimant. The Judge found the transfer to the sister was exactly that, and rejected her claim that earlier financial help had given her a real stake in the property, there being no clear agreement or documentary support. The set-aside was suspended briefly to let the family raise the money another way, and the father was ordered to pay costs on a more punitive "indemnity" basis.
Implications:
The first lesson is that a duty to support your children is ongoing and hard to escape. Choosing to earn less does not discharge any defined responsibility, and neither does leaving the country – the obligation, and the means of enforcing it, follow the parent and their assets wherever they may roam. Where future payment appears precarious, the Court can convert future maintenance into an immediate lump sum.
The second is that attempting to transfer assets out of reach rarely works, and often only succeeds in making things worse. A transfer made with the intention of defeating a claim – whether to a relative, a friend or a company – can be reversed under Section 423, and that purpose does not have to be the only reason for the transfer, merely a real one. Any relative who receives the asset will need genuine evidence of their own stake, such as a clear agreement or a documented financial contribution, to keep it.
This case also serves as a reminder of how revealing documents can be. Here, the father's own emails to his solicitors were used to establish that the transfer was intended to frustrate the children's claim, and it is surprising how often parties forget that such correspondence can come to light.
Finally, conduct of this kind carries a sting in this cautionary tale. The father faced further costs on an indemnity basis, a punitive measure expressing the Court's evident disapproval of his conduct, leaving the paying party covering far more than solely the other side's legal costs. Anyone facing a dispute over child provision, on either side, should take early advice rather than resorting to such ill-advised evasive strategies that a court can readily undo.
Disclaimer: This simplified summary of a UK legal case is for general information only. It is not legal advice, may omit important detail, and may not reflect later developments or appeals. Please read the full judgement and seek professional legal advice before acting.